Encapsulation of Email over Delay-Tolerant Networks(DTN) using the Bundle Protocol

Abstract

This document describes the encapsulation of emails using RFC2442 format in the payload of bundles of the Bundle Protocol for the use case of Delay-Tolerant Networks(DTN) such as in space communications.¶

1. Introduction

An important use case of Delay-Tolerant Networks(DTN) using the Bundle Protocol[RFC9171] is in space communications. Current scenarios by space agencies[ioag] involves the use of an IP network on the planetary body and the use of the Bundle Protocol between planetary bodies, including Earth. Therefore, there are IP endpoints at both ends, and then bundles could be used as a transport of Internet related application payload. This document describes the encapsulation of emails over bundles so that end-users on the remote end (aka on a planetary body such as Moon or Mars) or processes can use typical Internet Email software and tools to use emails, while the emails when transiting in space is encapsulated into bundles of the Bundle Protocol.¶

It should be noted that in DTNs, delays may be very large compared to normal delays on (Earth) Internet. Therefore, the SMTP [RFC5321] "conversation" between the two SMTP peers should be avoided since it will take many round-trips over long delays networks to achieve the delivery. Therefore, this document proposes to encapsulate the whole Email, including the envelope, using the Batch SMTP media-type [RFC2442] as a single file into bundles of the Bundle Protocol.¶

2. Description

In a typical scenario, the email would be created on (Earth) Internet, sent using regular delivery (DNS MX records, SMTP, ...) to a destination address that points to a location on a planetary body. That email would arrive to an SMTP server which is connected to the Bundle agent[RFC9171] capable of routing bundles to the final Bundle agent on the other planetary body, who has also a connection to an SMTP server. That SMTP server on the other planetary body is responsible for final delivery on that planetary body network. The target bundle protocol service number contained in the bundle is the one allocated by IANA per this document.¶

TBD: artwork representation¶

This document assumes that there is a close interaction between a Mail Transfer Agent(MTA) and a Bundle protocol agent, in, for example, the form of interprocess communication. However, the specific interaction is outside the scope of this document and is left to the implementation.¶

3. Encapsulation

The payload of the bundle [RFC9171] is a Batch SMTP media-type content [RFC2442] that includes both the email itself and the envelope. A bundle can only contain a single email.¶

If the email is too large to fit in a single bundle, then the bundle agent uses bundle fragmentation as described in section 5.8 of [RFC9171] to slice the email into multiple bundles. It is the responsability of the receiving bundle agent to properly reassemble the multiple bundle payloads into the source email.¶

The receiving bundle agent will receive the email-containing bundle(s) on this document specifically assigned IANA service number. The agent transfers the email to a Mail Transfer Agent(MTA) that will deliver to the appropriate location as normal practice on Internet.¶

4. Considerations

Configuring and deploying an isolated IP network on a planetary body with local mail servers, DNS servers and email client needs careful consideration. For example, emails sent between two end-users on the same planetary body should not go through space links down to Earth and back to the planetary body. This operational consideration is not described here and is outside the scope of this document.¶

By using the encapsulation of emails using the [RFC2442] format, there is no negotiation and no declaration of capabilities as it is done in normal SMTP [RFC5321]. Therefore, the source endpoint has no way by this solution to know the capabilities of the other endpoint. Therefore, on the target planetary bodies MTAs should be properly configured to receive the appropriate kind of emails sent from another planetary body.¶

As with typical SMTP on Internet, it is very possible that either improper configuration or other reasons cause the destination MTA to reject the email. In this case, it should send an error using the same technique on the reverse path, if at least the From address is parsable. If the email is not parsable on the destination MTA, then normal operational logging shall be used. Similarly to the previous paragraph, this consideration of non-negotiation of capabilities is not described here and is outside the scope of this document. It is however expected that this environment will be highly configured and managed, so that such issues shall not happen often.¶

It should be noted that attachments to emails will be part of this encapsulation mechanism by default.¶

5. Use case where the endpoint is only a BP agent

There are cases such as a spacecraft currently moving in space where there might be no IP network attached to it and has only a BP agent. This specification works also as is in this use case, if that device is augmented by a local IP stack, with an SMTP listener, where the final source or destination of the SMTP packet is within the spacecraft.¶

6. Alternatives

There are other ways to send email for this use case.¶

• JMAP (RFC8620) could be used but would require http encapsulation over bundle protocol.¶
• JMAP (RFC8620) JSON encoding of its data model could be encapsulated with a media-type similarly to Batch SMTP.¶
• Batch SMTP could be also encapsulated into a file transfer protocol such as CFDP and then MTA on both sides would have to watch the directory for new uploaded files and act upon those new files.¶
• A file synchronization mechanism such as rsync over some transport could also be used.¶
• Inventing a new mail protocol native over bundle protocol¶

There are probably other ways to acheive the same goal. However, we believe this specification is the most simple and effective way. An implementation is pretty straightforward and could leverage all software and experience of Internet mail. For example, with this solution, it would be possible for an astronaut to use his mobile phone mail application to read his email while not knowing it has been carried over bundle protocol for some portions of the path.¶

9. References